PhD Dissertation Project
Identifying Barriers to Social Service Access in Kangra, India
Problem
India is one of the world’s most densely multilingual countries, and the Himalayas hold some of its most multilingual societies. That linguistic diversity shapes how poverty alleviation programs work in everyday practice.
Rural women often face challenges accessing state services because of how differently the people in these encounters speak.
Question
How does linguistic diversity shape administration and access to social services among rural women in Himachal Pradesh, India?
Methods
For my PhD dissertation, I conducted five individual studies over twenty-one months of ethnographic fieldwork in Kangra, working with five state and non-state agencies. I wanted to understand how bureaucrats, NGO workers, elected officials, activists, and rural citizens use their multilingual repertoires to administer and access state services.
Who I worked with
- State bureaucrats
- NGO workers
- Elected officials
- Activists
- Rural citizens
How I gathered data
- Participant observation
- Audiovisual ethnography
- Interviewing
- Focus groups
- News and social media analysis
- Photography
How I analyzed it
- Discourse analysis of everyday interactions
- Emergent coding
- Participant composites
- Data visualization (NVivo 12)
- Transcription and coding of audiovisual data (ELAN)
Findings
Language alone was an insufficient predictor of how and why women could access state services. What mattered was how people used different languages, in culturally specific ways.
Language access, meaning being unable to understand one another, was the root cause of barriers for rural women.
Everyone used a variety of languages. How they used them was the greatest predictor of who gained access to services in the ways they wanted.
How it worked
I identified several linguistic strategies that let service providers decide what poverty, prosperity, and deservingness mean in everyday interactions.
Linguistic strategies
Specific registers, grammatical resources, and metapragmatic features, meaning talk about language itself.
Meaning-making
Providers settled the meanings of poverty, prosperity, and deservingness in the moment.
Who gets access
These processes directly shaped who could and could not access state services.
Impact
I shared my findings with multiple state agencies. They used the data to start conversations about new procedures for benefit selection, professional conduct for state agents, and the exclusionary nature of existing practices.
Reform efforts, led by activists on the ground, have changed the conversation about equity in rural development.